Incompatabiliy with FIBPlus

[Jonathan Neve [Microtec]]

Hi,

Is anyone else using EL version 5 with FIBPlus? Ever since I installed
the new version of EL (without changing my FIBPlus version), I've had
occasionnal, illogical and difficult to reproduce access violations in
certain FIBPlus units. I suppose there must be some incompatibility
between EL and FIBPlus (if it were just a FIBPlus bug, I would have had
it even with the old version of EL). Has anyone else experienced this?
FYI, I'm using BCB version 5.

Thanks in advance!
--
Best regards,
Jonathan Neve
_______________
CopyCat - advanced database replication
components for Delphi/C++Builder!
_______________________________________
e-mail: jonathan@microtec.fr
web : http://www.microtec.fr/CopyCat/index.html

[Dmitry Skrizhewsky]

I don't see incompatibility between Fib+ and EL. Must be your bug.



"Jonathan Neve [Microtec]" <jonathan@microtec.fr> ???????/???????? ?
???????? ?????????: news:dfrrgd$cgb$1@server.eurekalog.com...
> Hi,
>
> Is anyone else using EL version 5 with FIBPlus? Ever since I installed the
> new version of EL (without changing my FIBPlus version), I've had
> occasionnal, illogical and difficult to reproduce access violations in
> certain FIBPlus units. I suppose there must be some incompatibility
> between EL and FIBPlus (if it were just a FIBPlus bug, I would have had it
> even with the old version of EL). Has anyone else experienced this? FYI,
> I'm using BCB version 5.
>
> Thanks in advance!
> --
> Best regards,
> Jonathan Neve
> _______________
> CopyCat - advanced database replication
> components for Delphi/C++Builder!
> _______________________________________
> e-mail: jonathan@microtec.fr
> web : http://www.microtec.fr/CopyCat/index.html

[Jonathan Neve [Microtec]]

Dmitry Skrizhewsky wrote:
> I don't see incompatibility between Fib+ and EL. Must be your bug.

No, it's not my bug. :)

What Delphi/BCB version do you use? It's probably a BCB compatability
problem...
--
Best regards,
Jonathan Neve
_______________
CopyCat - advanced database replication
components for Delphi/C++Builder!
_______________________________________
e-mail: jonathan@microtec.fr
web : http://www.microtec.fr/CopyCat/index.html

[Jonathan Neve [Microtec]]

Jonathan Neve [Microtec] wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Is anyone else using EL version 5 with FIBPlus? Ever since I installed
> the new version of EL (without changing my FIBPlus version), I've had
> occasionnal, illogical and difficult to reproduce access violations in
> certain FIBPlus units. I suppose there must be some incompatibility
> between EL and FIBPlus (if it were just a FIBPlus bug, I would have had
> it even with the old version of EL). Has anyone else experienced this?
> FYI, I'm using BCB version 5.
>
> Thanks in advance!

Here's a little test-case that reproduces the problem systematically. It turns out
that if I generate an SQL error (using invalid SQL) an access violation happens
somewhere, and EL reports it. I know this sometimes happens even without an SQL
error, but this seems to be the same underlying problem, since EL reports the
exception in the same source files.

I'm not sure that this is really a EurekaLog bug, it seems rather to be related to
FIBPlus, but I'm not quite sure, and so that's why I'm reporting it both here, and to
the FIBPlus developpers. Using the following test case you should at least be able to
confirm whether or not this is a EurekaLog problem.

The test case requires BCB 5 and FIBPlus (you can use the evaluation version if you
don't have it). Thanks in advance.
--
Best regards,
Jonathan Neve
_______________
CopyCat - advanced database replication
components for Delphi/C++Builder!
_______________________________________
e-mail: jonathan@microtec.fr
web : http://www.microtec.fr/CopyCat/index.html

[admin]

Jonathan Neve [Microtec] wrote:
> Jonathan Neve [Microtec] wrote:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> Is anyone else using EL version 5 with FIBPlus? Ever since I installed
>> the new version of EL (without changing my FIBPlus version), I've had
>> occasionnal, illogical and difficult to reproduce access violations in
>> certain FIBPlus units. I suppose there must be some incompatibility
>> between EL and FIBPlus (if it were just a FIBPlus bug, I would have
>> had it even with the old version of EL). Has anyone else experienced
>> this? FYI, I'm using BCB version 5.
>>
>> Thanks in advance!
>
>
> Here's a little test-case that reproduces the problem systematically. It
> turns out that if I generate an SQL error (using invalid SQL) an access
> violation happens somewhere, and EL reports it. I know this sometimes
> happens even without an SQL error, but this seems to be the same
> underlying problem, since EL reports the exception in the same source
> files.
>
> I'm not sure that this is really a EurekaLog bug, it seems rather to be
> related to FIBPlus, but I'm not quite sure, and so that's why I'm
> reporting it both here, and to the FIBPlus developpers. Using the
> following test case you should at least be able to confirm whether or
> not this is a EurekaLog problem.
>
> The test case requires BCB 5 and FIBPlus (you can use the evaluation
> version if you don't have it). Thanks in advance.

I'm trying to reproduce your problem but to do this I need your .GDB file.
Can you send it to me please (in private)?

--
Best regards...

Fabio Dell'Aria.

[Jonathan Neve [Microtec]]

admin wrote:
> I'm trying to reproduce your problem but to do this I need your .GDB file.
> Can you send it to me please (in private)?

Ah yes, indeed. Actually, any GDB will do, as my SQL is "Select * from rdb$test",
which will fail anywhere. :) I'll send you a little GDB for doing the test.
--
Best regards,
Jonathan Neve
_______________
CopyCat - advanced database replication
components for Delphi/C++Builder!
_______________________________________
e-mail: jonathan@microtec.fr
web : http://www.microtec.fr/CopyCat/index.html

[admin]

Jonathan Neve [Microtec] wrote:
> admin wrote:
>
>> I'm trying to reproduce your problem but to do this I need your .GDB
>> file.
>> Can you send it to me please (in private)?
>
>
> Ah yes, indeed. Actually, any GDB will do, as my SQL is "Select * from
> rdb$test", which will fail anywhere. :) I'll send you a little GDB for
> doing the test.

The last 5.0.3 version fixes definitely your problem! :)


--
Best regards...

Fabio Dell'Aria.
----------------
http://www.eurekalog.com
Catch every BUG showing line n.